{
  "name": "research-progress",
  "description": "Explicit as-of research progress: present states, dated editorial corrections, recorded decisions and support limits; unknown historical baseline stays unknown.",
  "license": "Charitology schema and editorial material: CC BY 4.0; cite “Charitology (charitology.org)”. External data and documents retain their own source-specific terms, attribution and exceptions. This notice does not license third-party source material.",
  "generated": "2026-11-07",
  "data": {
    "editionId": "edition:2026-11-07-encyclopedia",
    "editionHash": "e146b1666792c4b20504af099ca65663d0f70fea584397f38cb5eda241137bde",
    "period": {
      "from": "2026-01-01T00:00:00.000Z",
      "to": "2026-11-07T23:20:18.679Z"
    },
    "coverage": {
      "baselineKnownFrom": null,
      "limitations": [
        "This initial capture establishes current draft coverage, not a known January baseline or an earlier status history.",
        "The one PR-backed artifact is an editorial correction to two claim subjects; it is not a scientific result, independent review or problem resolution.",
        "Source-derived case descriptions and manuscript bylines do not establish performed Charitology fieldwork or documented complete human authorship.",
        "Public GitHub observations describe only the named objects at their recorded inspection time. An empty returned review list is not proof about reviews elsewhere.",
        "The encyclopedia extension records exact draft wording at its separate capture. It supplies no independent source review, documented complete human authorship or earlier history."
      ],
      "sourceKeys": [
        "cases/carnegie-libraries",
        "cases/dare",
        "cases/green-revolution",
        "cases/haiti-earthquake-reconstruction",
        "cases/hookworm-campaign",
        "cases/ice-bucket-challenge",
        "cases/one-laptop-per-child",
        "cases/oral-rehydration-therapy-spread",
        "cases/playpumps",
        "cases/polio-eradication",
        "cases/rosenwald-schools",
        "cases/scared-straight",
        "cases/smallpox-eradication",
        "encyclopedia/beneficiary-feedback",
        "encyclopedia/charity-as-a-system",
        "encyclopedia/cost-effectiveness-analysis",
        "encyclopedia/counterfactual-impact",
        "encyclopedia/discounting",
        "encyclopedia/donor-advised-funds",
        "encyclopedia/effective-altruism",
        "encyclopedia/expected-value",
        "encyclopedia/identifiable-victim-effect",
        "encyclopedia/impact-investing",
        "encyclopedia/moral-uncertainty",
        "encyclopedia/mutual-aid",
        "encyclopedia/neglectedness",
        "encyclopedia/outputs-and-outcomes",
        "encyclopedia/overhead-ratio",
        "encyclopedia/participatory-grantmaking",
        "encyclopedia/private-foundations",
        "encyclopedia/psychic-numbing",
        "encyclopedia/randomized-controlled-trials",
        "encyclopedia/restricted-and-unrestricted-funding",
        "encyclopedia/scale-neglectedness-tractability",
        "encyclopedia/source-depth",
        "encyclopedia/symptoms-and-sources",
        "encyclopedia/systemic-change",
        "encyclopedia/theory-of-change",
        "encyclopedia/warm-glow-giving",
        "journal/depth-without-a-ladder",
        "journal/ten-dollars",
        "journal/the-feedback-contract",
        "problems/closing-the-feedback-loop",
        "problems/discounting-the-future",
        "problems/measuring-the-source",
        "problems/moral-parliament-in-practice",
        "problems/proximity-and-obligation",
        "problems/story-without-bias",
        "problems/the-agency-premium",
        "problems/the-counterfactual-problem",
        "problems/the-depth-census",
        "problems/the-enough-question",
        "problems/the-exchange-rate-problem",
        "problems/the-failure-commons",
        "problems/the-fragmentation-question",
        "problems/the-government-question",
        "problems/the-money-time-exchange",
        "problems/the-optimal-restriction",
        "problems/the-overhead-replacement",
        "problems/the-payout-question",
        "problems/the-profession-question",
        "problems/the-question-of-questions",
        "problems/the-replication-rate",
        "problems/the-status-flip",
        "problems/when-charity-harms",
        "record/methodology"
      ]
    },
    "startingStates": [
      {
        "recordId": "problem:closing-the-feedback-loop",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:discounting-the-future",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:measuring-the-source",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:moral-parliament-in-practice",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:proximity-and-obligation",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:story-without-bias",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-agency-premium",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-counterfactual-problem",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-depth-census",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-enough-question",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-exchange-rate-problem",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-failure-commons",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-fragmentation-question",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-government-question",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-money-time-exchange",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-optimal-restriction",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-overhead-replacement",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-payout-question",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-profession-question",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-question-of-questions",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-replication-rate",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-status-flip",
        "status": null
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:when-charity-harms",
        "status": null
      }
    ],
    "endingStates": [
      {
        "recordId": "problem:closing-the-feedback-loop",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:discounting-the-future",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:measuring-the-source",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:moral-parliament-in-practice",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:proximity-and-obligation",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:story-without-bias",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-agency-premium",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-counterfactual-problem",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-depth-census",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-enough-question",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-exchange-rate-problem",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-failure-commons",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-fragmentation-question",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-government-question",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-money-time-exchange",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-optimal-restriction",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-overhead-replacement",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-payout-question",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-profession-question",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-question-of-questions",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-replication-rate",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:the-status-flip",
        "status": "open"
      },
      {
        "recordId": "problem:when-charity-harms",
        "status": "open"
      }
    ],
    "dispositionsRecorded": [],
    "currentlySupportedDispositionIds": [],
    "supportWithdrawals": [],
    "editorialCorrections": [
      "artifact:pr-3-editorial-framing"
    ],
    "changedClaimIds": [
      "claim:depth-census-knowledge",
      "claim:ten-dollars-framing"
    ],
    "reviewEvents": [],
    "undatedEvents": [
      "event:case-carnegie-libraries-1",
      "event:case-dare-1",
      "event:case-green-revolution-1",
      "event:case-haiti-earthquake-reconstruction-1",
      "event:case-hookworm-campaign-1",
      "event:case-ice-bucket-challenge-1",
      "event:case-one-laptop-per-child-1",
      "event:case-oral-rehydration-therapy-spread-1",
      "event:case-playpumps-1",
      "event:case-polio-eradication-1",
      "event:case-rosenwald-schools-1",
      "event:case-scared-straight-1",
      "event:case-smallpox-eradication-1",
      "event:claim-depth-census-knowledge-1",
      "event:claim-ten-dollars-framing-1",
      "event:concept-beneficiary-feedback-1",
      "event:concept-charity-as-a-system-1",
      "event:concept-cost-effectiveness-analysis-1",
      "event:concept-counterfactual-impact-1",
      "event:concept-discounting-1",
      "event:concept-donor-advised-funds-1",
      "event:concept-effective-altruism-1",
      "event:concept-expected-value-1",
      "event:concept-identifiable-victim-effect-1",
      "event:concept-impact-investing-1",
      "event:concept-moral-uncertainty-1",
      "event:concept-mutual-aid-1",
      "event:concept-neglectedness-1",
      "event:concept-outputs-and-outcomes-1",
      "event:concept-overhead-ratio-1",
      "event:concept-participatory-grantmaking-1",
      "event:concept-private-foundations-1",
      "event:concept-psychic-numbing-1",
      "event:concept-randomized-controlled-trials-1",
      "event:concept-restricted-and-unrestricted-funding-1",
      "event:concept-scale-neglectedness-tractability-1",
      "event:concept-source-depth-1",
      "event:concept-symptoms-and-sources-1",
      "event:concept-systemic-change-1",
      "event:concept-theory-of-change-1",
      "event:concept-warm-glow-giving-1",
      "event:manuscript-depth-without-a-ladder-1",
      "event:manuscript-ten-dollars-1",
      "event:manuscript-the-feedback-contract-1",
      "event:method-methodology-1",
      "event:problem-closing-the-feedback-loop-1",
      "event:problem-discounting-the-future-1",
      "event:problem-measuring-the-source-1",
      "event:problem-moral-parliament-in-practice-1",
      "event:problem-proximity-and-obligation-1",
      "event:problem-story-without-bias-1",
      "event:problem-the-agency-premium-1",
      "event:problem-the-counterfactual-problem-1",
      "event:problem-the-depth-census-1",
      "event:problem-the-enough-question-1",
      "event:problem-the-exchange-rate-problem-1",
      "event:problem-the-failure-commons-1",
      "event:problem-the-fragmentation-question-1",
      "event:problem-the-government-question-1",
      "event:problem-the-money-time-exchange-1",
      "event:problem-the-optimal-restriction-1",
      "event:problem-the-overhead-replacement-1",
      "event:problem-the-payout-question-1",
      "event:problem-the-profession-question-1",
      "event:problem-the-question-of-questions-1",
      "event:problem-the-replication-rate-1",
      "event:problem-the-status-flip-1",
      "event:problem-when-charity-harms-1"
    ],
    "lateBackfills": [
      "event:artifact-pr-3-editorial-framing-1"
    ],
    "counters": {
      "dispositionsRecorded": 0,
      "currentlySupportedDispositions": 0,
      "editorialCorrections": 1,
      "changedClaims": 2
    },
    "limitations": [
      "This initial capture establishes current draft coverage, not a known January baseline or an earlier status history.",
      "The one PR-backed artifact is an editorial correction to two claim subjects; it is not a scientific result, independent review or problem resolution.",
      "Source-derived case descriptions and manuscript bylines do not establish performed Charitology fieldwork or documented complete human authorship.",
      "Public GitHub observations describe only the named objects at their recorded inspection time. An empty returned review list is not proof about reviews elsewhere.",
      "The encyclopedia extension records exact draft wording at its separate capture. It supplies no independent source review, documented complete human authorship or earlier history.",
      "Counts describe this pinned ledger; absent starting evidence is unknown, not an assumed January baseline."
    ],
    "inputHash": "11ebcd1bf4ed917ed4752c19be63330628b7bd7948d39ea6826fdbf7b123dc07"
  }
}